
Disney's Alice is shocked by What Tim Burton Did.
Alice in Wonderland came out! I didn’t realise it was anywhere near ready!
What I wasn’t ready for was that it wasn’t Alice as I remember her, a confused vulnerable and fairly whimsical girl. This was Hollywood Alice. Complete with bravery, an imaginary (or not) world nicely in parallel with the real to help her overcome her problems and talking magical creature-friends that now aid her on her path to betterification, rather than just mess with her.
The thing is I’m not sure why. Or why anything that happens here happens for that matter. Contrary to the original’s intended lack of good solid sense, this just plain refuses to explain the characters motivations; which seem to have developed since Alice’s last visit from having tea to insurrection and revolution with gothic overtones to leave you with a funny Narnia-Esq. feeling. Perhaps Burton got them mixed up. There is also nothing unpredictable here despite bearing little relation to the novels, Alan Rickman even provides a book that tells us exactly what will happen.

Miranda Richarson might as well have been the Queen of Hearts
Queenie, played by Helena Bonham-Carter, was far too close to being straight out of Blackadder and if Carter hadn’t noticed then surely Melchett should have had the stones to point it out. That they never thought it might not go down well with a British audience raised on Curtis and Elton’s masterful depiction of Elizabeth I beggars belief.
I think what particularly fails though is some of the choices of media. The soundtrack I found excellent throughout the piece, until the credits. Then Avril Lavigne blasted out and removed any sense of glorious frivolity that was left in Burton’s barren Narnia. Why do this!? It is unnecessary, especially if you already have a talented composer, to switch so sharply to that rubbish. Another sticking point was the Johnny Depp ‘dance’ near the end that only leaves a hollow inside. I was actually embarrassed.
The entire film had been dark and grungy, to my previously stated distaste, and then thrown in is something from Alvin and the Chipmunks possibly to lighten the mood. It only blackened mine.
However.

Stephen Fry's weightless Feline
Much of that was just me being picky; on a happier note the film was gorgeous. Everything was vivid and snactacular as you could imagine. The Cheshire Cat was fantastic. I loved his lazy movement, the pawing of the Hatter’s hat and that he was Stephen Fry. I loved that over half the actors were British, something that actually can be quite important in a subject as treasured as this. I liked that Sauraman was in it. I even liked the obsession with stabbing people in the eyes.
There is a lot to be said for this portrayal of Wonderland then if you accept it stand alone. There is fighting, there is a land of wonder, there are beasties and there is beauty.
There is not a lot of truth, but sometimes you just have to give up expecting Hollywood to deliver a faithful rendition of a beloved and complex literary classic.
Oh and I know I haven’t said a lot about Alice herself, that’s because she’s not the central character anymore.
(For the magic of the old Wonderland check this out: Alice in Wonderland)
Alice in Wonderland came out! I didn’t even realise it was anywhere near ready! What I wasn’t ready for was that it wasn’t Alice as I remember her, a confused, vulnerable and fairly whimsical girl. This was Hollywood Alice. Complete with bravery, an imaginary (or not) world nicely in parallel with the real to help her overcome her problems and talking magical creature-friends that now aid her on her path to betterification, rather than just mess with her. The thing is I’m not sure why. Or why anything that happens here happens for that matter. Contrary to the original’s intended lack of good solid sense, this just plain refuses to explain the characters motivations, which seem to have developed since Alice’s last visit from having tea to insurrection and revolution leaving you with a funny Narnia-Esq. feeling. Perhaps Burton got them mixed up. There is also nothing unpredictable here despite bearing little relation to the novels, Alan Rickman even provides a book that tells us exactly what will happen.Queenie, played by Helena Bonham-Carter, was far too close to being straight out of Blackadder and if Carter hadn’t noticed then surely Melchett should have had the stones to point it out. That they never thought it might not go down well with a British audience raised on Curtis and Elton’s masterful depiction of Elizabeth I beggars belief. I think what particularly fails though is some of the choices of media. The soundtrack I found excellent throughout the piece, until the credits. Then Avril Lavigne blasted out and removed any sense of glorious frivolity that was left in Burton’s barren Narnia. Why do this!? It is unnecessary, especially if you already have a talented composer, to switch so sharply to that Canadian pseudo-gothic drivel. Another sticking point was the Johnny Depp ‘dance’ near the end that only leaves a hollow inside. I was actually embarrassed. The entire film had been dark and grungy and then thrown in is something from Alvin and the Chipmunks to, I suppose, lighten the mood. It blackened mine. However.
Much of that was just me being picky; on a happier note the film was gorgeous. Everything was vivid and snactacular as you could imagine. The Cheshire Cat was fantastic. I loved the laziness of his movement, the pawing of the Hatter’s hat and that it was Stephen Fry. I loved that over half the actors were British, something that actually can be quite important in a subject as treasured as this. I liked that Sauraman was in it. I even liked the obsession with stabbing people in the eyes.
There is a lot to be said for this portrayal of Wonderland then if you accept it stand alone. There is fighting, there is a land of wonder, there are beasties and there is beauty.
There is not a lot of truth. But sometimes you just have to give up expecting Hollywood to deliver a faithful rendition of a beloved complex literary classic and instead argue over the correct colour scheme.
Oh and I know I haven’t said a lot about Alice herself, that’s because she’s not the central character anymore, good as the actor was.